If you plan to transform digitally, you are actually asking yourself the ‘wrong’ question. Clarify first what you want to achieve, e.g. what customer/business metrics do you want to improve? Only then, structure your transformation and deploy people around it.

The goal of this article is to create awareness on what successful organisations on digital transformation do differently

A few definitions of Digitisation, Digitalisation and Digital Transformation can be found at the bottom of this article to bring some clarity.

In the last decade, we have seen numerous Digital Transformations that have failed. As a reminder, 80% of all Transformations fail partly or fully (so many HBR Articles on this). And typically, they do not fail on the technical side, technology does almost always work in the end…

We have observed three main causes for this failure:

1. Lack of Clarity on what the business Goals are. No measurable metric.

You do not digitise to improve your business. You improve your business through digitisation. That is not a play of words. You need to decide first, what do you want to improve and what do you want to transform. Improve is the typical step by step continuous improvement that will gradually take you to your end goal as oppose Transform which is rethinking your approach completely in order to achieve a step change. Both approaches are complementary but they are different in nature in the sense that Transform will require thinking outside the box to achieve a step change as opposed to improve where you are continuously improving the way of doing things. That being said, let you want to transform; do you want to increase customer satisfaction, customer intimacy? Do you want to be more efficient? Cut cycle time ? Cut costs ? Once you are clear on where you want to go and what business metrics you want to improve, then you need to move to Deployment, and later to Execution, and once there, Digitalisation will play its role and will facilitate achieving your goals.

2. No Improvement of key processes and interfaces first.

We have witnessed so many Digitalisation where no business metric gets improved after millions of dollars/euros have been swallowed by Digitalisation Consultants. This is indeed big business for those firms. In a recent personal conversation, an IT Consultant was explaining to me that you need to digitise everything first, then you can see where the problems are and improve from there. I personally think there is a conflict of interest in this approach… There is also huge pressure for all organisations to be digital. But shouldn’t the pressure be on being close to customers, product and profits instead? Looking at your Value Streams and fixing key Customer Pain Points and Internal Processes first will bring you much more business impact than putting digitalisation first. It might sound less sexy though. If not, you risk to digitise your processes twice, once for the current state and the second time around based on improved processes. This will more than double the costs of the program, not to mention its cycle time, and even after the second time you might not improve the level of the business metrics you wanted. Simply because you did not define this first. The important message here is that technology comes after people and process. Not because it is less important, but because it is a servant to people and process, not the other way around! And don’t get me wrong here; we are big fans of digitalisation! We are simply highlighting the right order.

3. Lack of Change Leadership

The traditional way is that the whole focus (AND Budget) goes for the IT part including Project Management of course. But how do we ensure that the middle management and the employees are on board? Typically, organisations will perform what we call Change Administration. Regular Communications are planned before the Transformation and throughout, employees events are made in the townhall. The Intranet post updates and success stories while senior management randomly meets some employees to keep in touch. And by doing all that, those organisations still land in the 80% that fail…

What most organisations fail to understand is that while they are quite good at planning a business workstream, they forget to plan and deploy a people workstream. Involving Middle Management in deploying the Transformation, planning successes on the people workstream, deciding on what rituals to change and how, not to mention even basic training on how to deal with resistance to change to all People managers (the ones what will obviously face the resistance…) is simply not done.

SOME DEFINITIONS

There are quite different definitions existing out there. Lets take Wikipedia:

DIGITISATION

Wikipedia: Digitisation is the process of converting information into a digital format. Gartner’s IT Glossary“Digitisation is the process of changing from analog to digital form”, so very similar.

DIGITALISATION

If we move to Digitalisation, we get more confusion as several definitions are out there.

If we stay with Gartner, Digitalisation is the use of digital technologies to change a business model and provide new revenue and value-producing opportunities.

That sounds already quite different.

DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION

Wikipedia: Digital transformation (DX) is the adoption of digital technology by an organization.[1] Common goals for its implementation are to improve efficiency, value or innovationDigital transformation is the process of using digital technologies to create new — or modify existing — business processes, culture, and customer experiences to meet changing business and market requirements. This reimagining of business in the digital age is digital transformation.